Tag: hiring-freeze


新年快乐!

Robert here, writing from the Miami airport, about to head off to London. Happy Chinese New Year to all of our readers! Let’s hope the Year of the Tiger is a good one. It has been a very busy few weeks, mainly due to a relatively hot lateral recruiting market in HK / China (also, my hometown Saints winning the Super Bowl here in Miami was quite a wonderful distraction). Robert and I were in Hong Kong earlier this month and we will be visiting our Moscow offices and making the rounds at our firm clients there (along with our colleagues, Yuliya Vinokurova, our resident Moscow recruiter, and Daniel Roark) later this week for seven days. Robert was also in Shanghai earlier this month and I was in Tokyo and will be heading to Singapore from Moscow. Robert and I will be back in HK and SHG in March. Robert KinneyIn Hong Kong, Robert and I have been very much involved with the recent US firm rush to take on HK practices and that recruiting at the partner / group level has been fun, but quite intensive. Next week we will write about how this new important trend will affect US associate and counsel recruiting in HK in 2010. The HK / China biglaw US attorney lateral hiring market has most definitely picked up to the highest levels we have seen since mid ‘08. For example, in the past week, I made two placements in HK, one associate and one counsel. In January and February, I have 12 new associate hires starting their new jobs in HK / China. However, there are still far too many very qualified candidates on the market for the growing number of positions available. Thus, all major US and UK firms in HK / China can be extremely selective when filling openings. Also, there are still a handful of top US firms that remain on hiring freeze and a number of US and UK top firms in HK / China that are off hiring freeze but do not have the green light to hire for all their current needs. Firms falling into that latter category are typically focusing on cap markets hiring because of all the IPO deal flow that has been occurring in HK / China, although IPO work could fall off a little bit, temporarily, while the SHG and HK indexes have hit a snag recently. We believe there will be a further up tick in US associate lateral hiring in HK / China for the next month or two, as many partners we talk to were waiting until after the Chinese New Year holidays to ramp up recruiting efforts. Please do not be fooled though with what seems like a red hot lateral market in HK / China. It may seem the market is hotter than it really is because so many biglaw recruiters are trying to figure out how to break into the HK / China, the only hot biglaw lateral markets now. Surely, you have had a dramatic increase of cold calls recently, especially if you happen to be Chinese and / or have Mandarin fluency listed on your firm web bio. However, keep in mind that the biglaw deal flow in HK / China has been strong since last summer, especially in cap markets, and many firms have been understaffed by one or two associates for months. Now that most of these firms are relaxing their hiring freezes, at least somewhat, there is a spurt of hiring going on, due to pent up demand. I do not think this rate of hiring will continue for more than a few months before tapering off a bit. Since last fall, most top US firms in HK / China have been following a pattern of coming off hiring freeze and within one month hiring 2 to 4 new US associates, but then slowing down hiring substantially. For example, I placed 4 associates at one US firm’s HK offices from July to September last year; made 3 placements at another US firm’s HK and BJ offices in November and December; and made 3 placements at another US firm’s HK and BJ offices from December and January. There are a few more firms that we predict will come off hiring freeze soon and make similar hiring runs. Even with all the hiring going on in HK / China, as long as the US and other Western markets continue to be very slow biglaw lateral markets, there will be too big of an influx of qualified candidates in the HK / China markets for the amount of openings that exist. Thus, while in ‘06, ‘07 and ‘08, we were placing in HK / China US associates from a big variety of top US firms, in ‘09 and thus far in ‘10, the vast majority of US associate placements have been those coming from top 15 firms (more than half from top 5 firms). Further, all of our placements in ‘09 and thus far in ‘10 have had fluency in Mandarin, Japanese or Korean (while in the previous four years we were placing numerous English only associates in HK / China).


State of the Market, March 26, '09

Robert here. Although the lateral market in Asia continues to be very slow, as expected in the downturn, we have seen a substantial upturn in interviewing of our candidates in Asia recently. For example, currently the following of my associate candidates are actively interviewing in Asia, each at multiple firms (there are others with single interviews): *mid-level cap markets associate (Mandarin fluent) from HK interviewing in HK senior cap markets associate from HK (Mandarin fluent) interviewing in HK *mid-level PE / M&A associate from US interviewing in HK *mid-level M&A associate from US (Mandarin fluent) interviewing in HK *senior M&A / cap markets associate from US (Korean fluent) interviewing in HK *mid-level project finance associate from US (Korean fluent) interviewing in Tokyo *mid-level M&A associate from US (Mandarin fluent) interviewing in HK *mid-level M&A associate from HK (Mandarin fluent) interviewing in Beijing *mid-level IP associate from US (Mandarin fluent) interviewing in Beijing *mid-level project finance associate from US interviewing in Abu Dhabi *junior M&A associate from US (Mandarin fluent) interviewing in Beijing and HK *mid-level funds associate from US interviewing in HK It is important to note that firms are moving slow to give offers so the interviewing activity above is not indicative of offers coming soon for each (as it was during the recent boom times for lateral hiring). However, I am getting the impression that some firms are ready to give offers after some months of delay in filling openings. I do think that all the above associates will be placed in Asia in '09. Also, firms continue to be as selective as ever and each of the above associates are extremely well qualified, all coming from top practices and top law schools, with excellent grades. We are excited about the interview activity, though, as just two weeks ago the above list would have been only 1/3 as long. Some candidates who have been on hold since as far back as October are now being interviewed. We also have a number of partner candidates interviewing in HK / China, in practice areas such as project finance, M&A and IP. Going forward over the next several months I foresee continued interviewing and hiring in HK / China of very impressive M&A mid-level to senior associates (M&A, especially PE downstream work is relatively busy compared to other transactional areas in HK / China), as well as a handful of interviewing and hiring of cap markets and IP focused mid-level and senior associates. Keep in mind that a number of the most prestigious US firms in Asia have hiring freezes that are not going to thaw out any time too soon (at least until summer and likely longer), due to very strong cap markets practices that are down now (and that market will likely not pick up until some point in '10, unlike M&A that will likely turn around much quicker). Some firms that are in hiring freeze have asked us to send them top flight candidates in particular practice areas in order for them to have preliminary and informational conversations with such persons, whereas other frozen firms are not taking that approach. At many firms in Asia partners are still having some difficulty getting green lights from home offices on hires they would like / need to make. This is one reason why offers come slower. Further, unlike in a hot lateral market, firms are not worried too much about losing a great candidate to another firm because there are many great candidates on the market to choose from. This is one reason why even when China market picks up substantially (could happen as soon as 2nd half '09, but likely late '09 to early '10) (other Asia markets will likely be slower to rebound), firms will still move slow to make hires, as there will still be an overflow of candidates on the market until the US economy picks up substantially (likely after China). Also, until IPO work picks up substantially in China, a substantial number of top US firms in HK / China will continue to be overstaffed an on hiring freeze (except for critical hires needed). Things will be most difficult for junior US associate laterals because most US and British firms in Asia would rather try and figure out how to put their current junior cap markets associates to work (even if it means a re-tool) than hire new juniors (even if practice fit is better with potential lateral hire). Next week, I will go over some recent developments in M&A that have many of us in the HK / China market optimistic.